Notes:

1917 Jun 4, Mon. - Eastern High School Junior Shoots Man Entering His Home.
Charles Nolan, 16 Years of Age, Comes Down Stairs to Get Drink of Water, Detects Burglar, Who Grabs Him.
VICTIM DIES IN A LOCAL HOSPITAL. Believe to be Allen McCutcheon, who came her last Wednesday; May live at Winnipeg, Manitoba.
A man believe to be Allen McCutcheon off Winnipeg, Manitoba was show in the head & died at the Bay City hospital shortly after being removed to there, at about 1o'clock this Monday morning.
The shooting took place in the dining room of the residence of Mrs. Lillie Nolan, 1133 Wilson St. at 12:45 o'clock this Monday morning. Mrs. Nolan is a widow & keeps house for her brother, Charles J Winterhalter & her son Charles, a junior in Eastern high school, treasurer of the junior class.
Young Charles did the shooting with a 32 cabler revolver. The man was in the dining room of the Nolan home, having lifted a rear window & fell in his tracks over a low radiator under the window, he head falling on the floor where there remains a large clog of blood.
Officers Quick To the Scene. Chief Davis, Detectives Murphy & Gleason & other officers were quick to answer the call to the Nolan home & they spend the greater portion of the morning investigating ehe case. They required young Nolan to accompany them to the station after the shooting, but later released him when learning the full particulars of the case.

The Boys Story. Detected Man When Going For a Drink & was Grappled.
Young Nolan, to the officers who investigated the shooting, too the following story:
I had gone to bed & had been asleep only a short while when I woke up & when down to the kitchen to goat drink of water. While I was there I heard a noise out of doors.], when some boxes where struck together. I peered out the kitchen window & saw a man standing outside. I thought a first that he was going to steal my uncle's automobile, so I ran upstairs, pulled on my trousers & got the revolver. I crept quietly back to the kitchen, I again looked out, but could not see the man, so I stepped into the dining room & went to a rear window where I pulled the shade back to see if I could see anything of him from there. To my great surprise I found the man half way through the window & he jumped up & grabbed me.Then I shot & he fell. He did not say anything during our tussle & groaned a little when he fell. I then called my uncle who was asleep & he notified Ballard's store & the Bay City hospital ambulance was sent for.
Had His Shoes Off. McCutcheon, as the police believe the man to be, had no shoes on when he picked up in the Nolan home. He was also bareheaded & in his shirt sleeve. His had, a black felt hat 67.2 size & a brown coat were found on the back porch, but a search of the yard & the surrounding territory failed to find any trace of the shoes. However, about 10 o'clock, McCutcheon's shoes were found by Erwin Streeter in a pile of lumber in the alley back of the Nolan home, 3 doors to the north.They were not hidden but are where they could be easily picked up as McCutcheon let the house & went North.

Coroner Notified. After McCutcheon died at the Bay City hospital, Corner Kelly was notified. He directed that the body betaken to Erwell's morgue where it not is. McCutcheon is a may 23 to 35 years of age, 5 feet 9 or 10 inches in height & weights about 175 pounds. His hands were calloused, showing that he had been engaged in heavy work & his arms were muscular. There was a few days growth of whiskers & no mustache. His nose is long & angular. He wore a dark pair of trousers with a grayish strikethrough them, a blue short & white woolen undershirt.
The bullet entered the left side of the head about 2 inches about the ear & seems to have taken a slightly downward course.

Nolan a Slight Boy. Thought young Nolan had the grit to attack the intruder whom he believed to be a burglar, who he believed to be a burglar, he is a mere stripling, tall & straight, but weighting only 107 pounds. He would have been no match to McCutcheon. Nolan was born in the house where he lives. His father has been dead for 7 or 8 years. He is a junior in Eastern High school & treasurer of the class. He kept the class money in his home & his mother & uncle both had sums of money in the house. Nolan has a rallied complexion with slight color in the cheeks, dark eyes & heavy black eyelashes & eyebrows. He seemed quite unconcerned doubt the shooting, believing that if he had not shot that the would have been worsted by the burglar.

Came Here Last Wednesday, In the pocket of the coat was found a canceled traveling slip issued by the Michigan Railway company which shows that the bearer came from Saginaw to Bay City on May 30, last Wednesday. There was also a notebook with printed leaves showing how to mix various kinds of drinks. On the blank pages the owner had kept his working time at different places. It showed that he worked in Hamtramck, at Eloise on the Cedar dock from the 16 May to 4 July, & then went switching in Eloise until October 13. This is presumed to have been last year. Another notation says he then came over to Brandon on November 7. Brandon is in Oakland county. In the notebook the owner has jotted down the name of Roy Erwin, Co. F, 33rd Michigan, Fort Wayne, Detroit, Mich. There is also given the address of the Star Employment office, Cadillac, 1065, 7 & 9 W. Montcalm St. He also worked at 195 Territorial St. Benton Harbor.

A Letter From Mother. A later which seems to have come from his mother was found. The postscript says: Oh, I forgot to tell you I got a Xmas present from Minnie & Lizzie, a very nice silk necks cart, a Xmas card from Oscar & Eva. Vas. & Harold gave me a $1.25 box of writing paper & envelopes. Calla did not as much as send a Xmas card. It is surprising how ungrateful some can be. No more at this time. From your mother.

Coroner Kelly Makes Identification. From a paper that Coroner Kelly found on the body the dead man he decided that his name was Allen McCutcheon. Bearing this out was a line label inside a coat picket in which was printed the worlds Tip Top Tailors [i.e. made in Toronto, Ont.] & than on a blank space was written Mr. A McCutcheon, September 6.
Support this identification were other papers. There was a receipt for $5 given to A J McCutcheon, Sept 28, 1916. A pawn ticket no. 201 to A. McCutcheon for one 18 size silver watch, issued by Frank's loan office, River Rouge, Feb. 1, 1917, was also found. Also the stub of a pawn ticket No. 625. There was also a receipt for $5 made out to Minard McCutcheon by Drs. Smith & Hoode of Duluth, June 17, 1916. There was a Pullman ticket for an upper berth on a tourist sleeper, Winnipeg to Sudbury, Nov. 16. 1916. Another paper which gave the name & address of Celia McCutcheon, 228 Garry St., Winnipeg was found. She is supposed to be a sister or wife of the dead man. She is referred to in the letter from Mother. The following address also found, 1902 Missouri, Billings Park, Charles Rockwell. McCutcheon had $1.01 in his possession.

Mother is Very Excitable. The shooting seems total heavily upon the widowed mother. She recently underwent an operation is very nervous. She deplores the shooting & wishes that the man had been allowed to rob the house. Friends endeavored to calm her by saying that her son was perfectly justified in shooting the man; that if the burglar & been permitted to enter the home & ransack the house he might have killed some of the inmates, if discovered. - . -
Ref: Bay Times Newspaper, Bay City, Michigan.

1917 Jun 5, Tues. BROTHER TO CLAIM BODY OF DEAD MAN. Chief Davis Locates Relatives of Allen McCutcheon Shot Monday Morning.
Chief of Police Davis has succeeded in locating the relatives of Allen McCutcheon, who was host early Monday morning by Charles Nolan, 16 years old, while entering the home of the latter through widow. A telegram was sent to the chief of police at Superior, Wis. & in this way the chief here got into communication with a brother of the victim, S. McCutcheon, who is said by Charles J Vance, a roommate of the dead man to be an alderman in the city where he lives. Dances, late yesterday afternoon went to the police station after reading an account of the tragedy in the Times Tribune & then proceeded to the undertaking rooms of Geo. N Ewell, where he identified the dead man as his died & companion. Both came here only a few days ago & obtained employment at E B Foss & Co.'s lumber yard.
Vance said the last time he saw McCutcheon was early in the evening on Sunday night. At that time he was in a normal condition & he could not account for what subsequently took place. He further stated the McCutcheon's aged parents reside at Canfield, Manitoulin Island, Canada & that he family is highly respected.
This morning the chief of police received a telegram from S. McCutcheon, the victim's brother, requesting that the body be embalmed & that the would arrive in the city Wednesday night to take charge of it. Whether the burial will take place here, or the body taken to Canada is not known.

1917 Jun 7, Thus. R. McCutcheon, of Superior, Wis. arrived in Bay City last night to take charge of his brother, Allen McCutcheon, who was shot by Chas. Nolan, early Monday morning. The identification of the remains was complete. Mr. McCutcheon stated to the authorities that his relative was not a criminal, never having been in any kind of trouble before. He left with the remains at 10:55 today for Sandfield, Manitoulin Island, Canada, were the parents reside.

1917 June 8, Friday, Slaying of Allen McCutcheon was justifiable, coroner's Jury decides that has. Nolan acted in self-defense. …James Vance, companion of the dead man, who said he had known McCutcheon practically all his life, tested that he & McCutcheon came to Bay City together. They obtained a room & were dissatisfied with it & hunted up other quarters. On the night of the trouble the 2 parted about 8:30. Vance saying he went to the Salvation Army. McCutcheon was to meet him there. The latter did not show up. The witness could not account for what took place, declaring the his chum belonged to a good family & always behaved himself, never having gotten into serious trouble before. Other unimportant witnesses were called & then jury returned the follow verdict:
That Allen McCutcheon came to his death by a gun shot while entering the home of Chas. Winterhalter in the night time through a window, the shot being fired by Chas. Nolan in an act of self-defense, ming it in our opinion a justifiable act,
Ref: Bay City Times, Michigan. - . -

1917 - Manitoulin Man Shot in Michigan:
Victim of Shooting at Bay City is said to be Allen McCutcheon.
(Special Dispatch to the Globe).
Bay City, Michigan. June 4. Police tonight, it is said, definitely identified the man fatally shot today in the home of Charles J. Winterhalter, on the west side of the city. They claim he is Allen McCutcheon, 35 years old, & a resident of Manitoulin Island, Ontario.
The shooting occurred when McCutcheon tried, it is said, to force an entrance into the Winterhalter home through a window. Charles Nolan, a 16 year old nephew of the Winterhalters, heard the noise, & taking McCutcheon for a burglar, fired the shot which caused his death.
Charles Vance, a close friend of McCutcheon, says they came to Bay City from Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, a few weeks ago, & he is confident McCutcheon was killed by mistake.
The police theory is that the man attempted to make his way into the house, believing it to be his boarding place.
Ref: Globe Newspaper, Toronto, Ontario.
Transcripts by P J Ahlberg. Thank you. - - -
 

Buried:
Buried with parents on Manitoulin Island, Ontario.

Notes:

1872 Jun 0 - Two accidents of a serious nature have lately occurred in connection with the lumbering operations at Manitoulin Island. James McCutcheon, in the employ of Robert Adam Lyon & Co., was severely crushed whilst engaged in breaking roll-aways by the logs starting unexpectedly. He is recovering quite rapidly as could be expected under the circumstances.
Another employee named Ferguson had the better part of his foot cut off by the large circular saw. He had changed works? that morning with an acquaintance, & not being familiar with the work of tail sawing, got on the wrong side of the saw. Hence, the accident, which has maimed the poor fellow, probably for life. Both cases are progressing very favourably under the skillful direction of Dr. Simpson, Manitowaning.
Ref: Canadian Champion, Milton, published 6.20.1782 P2, Column 6.

Obituary,
The Late James McCutcheon:
On Thursday, December 14 at 3 o'clock PM another of the Island pioneers in the person of James McCutcheon passed away at the age of 71 after a prolonged illness. Mr. McCutcheon was born in the township of Adjala in the County of Dufferin in the year 1851. He came to the Manitoulin about 50 years ago to engage in the timber business, with the Robert Adam Lyon & Co. at Michaels Bay. The lure of the land soon led him to engage in the farming industry on an extensive scale in the township of Sandfield.
The well-known McCutcheon farm consisted of 500 Acres with a splendid house & large modern barns situated on the trunk road between Sandfield Mills & Manitowaning is a credit to our island. He was a natural lover of horses & livestock & more than 18 years ago the writer on his first visit to this farm was by Mr. McCutcheon a splendid herd of pure bred Registered Shorthorn Cattle.
In his earlier life Mr. McCutcheon devoted considerable time to Municipal affairs & for a number of years served his municipality as reeve with marked efficiency.
In 1875 he married Annie Hutchinson. This union was blest with 12 children of which 7 sons & 2 daughters are still living: Stewart of Duluth, Michigan; Minard of Spring Bay, Norman of Winnipeg, John of Bruce mines, Vesper, Harold & Clifford at home & Mrs. O. Lifton & Mrs. E. March & both of Vancouver B.C.
He is also survived by one sister, Mrs. Thomas Allen of Edmonton, & 1 brother, William, of the Niagara district, they being the youngest 2 of a family of 7.
The funeral service which was held at the family residence was conducted by the Rev. W.W. Anglin, a former pastor & friend of many years to the deceased & his family, who delivered a message of comfort to the bereaved & of tribute to the memory of the deceased. A very large number of sympathetic friends & neighbours were in attendance. The pall bearers were Minard, Naaman; Vesper; Harold; Clifford; sons of the deceased & William Tilson.
Mr. Hugh Little was in charge as undertaker & funeral director. Internment took place at Hilly Grove Cemetery. Mrs. McCutcheon & family have the sympathy of the entire community.
Ref: The Recorder, Gore Bay, Thursday, published January 4, 1923. - - -

Buried:
Manitoulin Island.

James married Anna HUTCHINSON on 30 Jun 1875 in Little Current, Manitoulin Island, Ontario. Anna was born on 28 Sep 1857 in Ontario, Canada; died in 1951 in Sandfield Twp., Manitoulin Island, Ontario; was buried in Hilly Grove Cemetery. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Notes:

Ann is the daughter of Melissa Martin & Richard Hutchinson.

1917 Jun 4, Monday - A Letter From Mother. A later which seems to have come from his mother was found. The postscript says: Oh, I forgot to tell you I got a Xmas present from Minnie & Lizzie, a very nice silk necks cart, a Xmas card from Oscar & Eva. Ves. & Harold gave me a $1.25 box of writing paper & envelopes. Calla [Cecilai?} did not as much as send a Xmas card. It is surprising how ungrateful some can be. No more at this time. From your mother.
X-Reference: Bay City Times Newspaper, Michigan. Extracted from the extensive report on the sad story of the robbery by & death of son Allen McCutcheon.
Ref: Bay City Times, Michigan.

Transcripts by P J Ahlberg. Thank you. - - -

Notes:

1905 - John Alexander was just a small child of 5 or 6 when he made the arduous journey across the Atlantic Ocean from Ireland to Quebec. He & Elizabeth put down roots on their farm in Adjala & remained there until their deaths. 2 of his 9 children (Agnes & Elizabeth- the oldest & the youngest) migrated west to a homestead outside Edmonton, Alberta. The death of John McCutcheon of Alliston removed one of Adjala's oldest settlers. 
Deceased is survived by 2 daughters who reside in the west & 3 sons, Robert of Mono Centre, James of Manitoulin Island; &William of Alliston. The remains were buried in Thompson's Cemetery.
Ref: 1905 Feb 22, Shelburne Free Press. - - -

Birth:
Sloanstown, Donaghadee, Irealnd

Buried:
Also called, Thompsons Cemetery, Adjala Twp., Simcoe Co.

John married Elizabeth ALLEN. Elizabeth was born in 1821 in County Down, Ireland; died on 26 Jan 1884 in Adjala Twp., Simcoe Co., Ontario; was buried in Rosemont Cemetery. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Notes:

Died:
- Died of fatty heart, four days.

Notes:

Living With Stewart & Sarah McCutcheon.
Samuel Brother Robert Stewart:

. 1825 Assessment & Census, Erin Twp., Wellington Co.
Robert McCutcheon, Males over 16: Two, Males under 16: One, Females over 16: One. Total Four.

. Obituary 1894 Feb 15m ERIN.
On Thursday, the 1st inst., death relieved Mr. Robert Stewart of his earthy cares forever. Deceased was an uncle of Mr. Stewart McCutcheon, the 3rd line, Erin, at whose place he died at the age of 85 years. Mr. Stewart was a native of County Down, Ireland, & came to Canada with his father & family in 1833. They settled in Lower Canada for a time.
His wife died in Montreal & he then removed to Erin & has for 15 years had a comfortable home with Mr. Stewart McCutcheon, his nephew. He was the last member of a family of nine, 3 of whom have died within 18 months, aged respectively 95, 92, & 85 years. The funeral was largely attended & was conducted by Revs. Reid & Baker.
Ref: Acton Free Press, p. 3, column 4.

1855 Jun 8, WILL of
"I ROBERT McCutcheon of the township of Arthur, County of Wellington & Province of Canada, Farmer, to make this my last Will & Testament in the following manner & form.  That is to say principally, & First - I give & allow my wife AGNES McCutcheon to have the use of all my land Estate & property which is Lot 30, W½, Con 1, Adjala Twp. together with  the N½, Con 3, Arthur, together with all my household furniture beds, tables, chairs & every moveable, together with cattle, horses, sheep & other animals now on the said Lots & also all implements of husbandry together with houses on the premises, to have & to hold all such during her natural life & to have the right of all monies, notes of any kind & every other thing which I possess.
I then give & bequeath to my son WILLIAM McCutcheon the S ½ Lot 16 Con 3, Arthur Twp. with freexxx & sufficient deed. I then give & bequeath to my son HUGH McCutcheon & to my daughter AGNES McCutcheon a sufficient maintenance & clothing during their natural lives, & that my son WILLIAM McCutcheon shall have the care of them as long as he does right by them, & that my Executors shall see the above performed, & in case of non performance justly the Executors shall have it in their power to change them to JAMES or ROBERT McCutcheon or any one else they may think would do justice by them.

Also I give & bequeath to my sons JOHN, HENRY McCutcheon, & JAMES McCutcheon, my sons XX of them 5 shillings one year after my buried & to my son ROBERT McCutcheon £5, this same money to be raised out of part of the chattle property on the premises by my Executors; & I hereby nominate & appoint JOHN McCutcheon & HENRY McCutcheon my 2 sons to be the Executors of this my last Will & Testament & to see that all things contained in this my last Will shall be performed. After the decease of my wife AGNES McCutcheon of this I would please God then take to my daughter AGNES McCutcheon away that the Adjala homestead shall be sold to one of my sons & the proceeds in 6 annual installments shall be equally divided to the aforesaid XX leaving HUGH McCutcheon the homestead in Arthur for his support during his natural life if unmarried & if married this deed to be made out in his own name by my Executors JOHN McCutcheon & HENRY McCutcheon. Thus declaring & signing this my last Will & Testament this 8th June, 1855.
Signed, ROBERT McCutcheon, JOHN BURCH, SARAH BURCH. - - -

Birth:
near Donaghadee Parish, Ireland.

Died:
Verify this Robert McCutcheon.

Buried:
Arthur, Ontario. Monument 4-7. Grey, square scraped, somewhat illegible monument; did perhaps once have a piller?

Robert married Agnes BECK. Agnes was born in 1790 in County Down, Ireland; died on 20 May 1873 in Cardwell, Adjala Twp., Simcoe Co., Ontario; was buried in Rosemont Cemetery. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Notes:

Birth:
Verify if also Grey Abbey.

Died:
Aged 83y Ref: tombstone.

Buried:
Also known as Thompson Methodist Pioneer Cemetery, Adjala Twp., Simcoe Co., Ontario.